In chapter 5, Legacies of Inequality of his
book Great American City, Sampson writes about place-paced disadvantage. He
follows other researchers in referring to Chicago as the “Black Metropolis” or
simply “black ghetto.” Sampson writes about a “poverty trap” and refers to it
as social disadvantages within neighborhoods and how such cycle is reinforced
by neighborhood structure as well as how it continues to repeat itself
throughout generations. He also mentions that the knot of inequality is far
greater in the black community than in the white community. Further he notes
that throughout the past forty years, the pattern of poverty has been moving
outward from inner cities.
According to Sampson, the problem is not how
individuals within a neighborhood change, “but whether and to what extent the
geographic concentration of poverty has become increasingly entrenched in
certain urban neighborhoods.” Further he notes that “poverty traps” cannot be
broken by individuals, but rather through interventions carried out by
government or large organization.
Yes, from 1995 – 2006, crime has decreased by
50% in Chicago as well as in the “black ghettos”, but the fact is that the
concentration of high violence persist and remains within the same old “hoods.”
In his March 29, 2013, New York Times
magazine article “The Death and Life of Chicago”, Ben Austin writes about how
individuals try to bring change to Chicago’s poorest neighborhoods. According
to the article two individuals teamed up and founded the Anti-Eviction Campaign.
Members of the campaign brake into vacant foreclosed homes, fix them up and
move homeless people into the “people-less” homes. As of this article they have
been broken into more than a hundred homes.
I strongly disagree with such “guerrilla activism”
and believe that it will take more than criminal acts by individual to change
the internal structure of a neighborhood. That’s right, to change the
place-paced disadvantages of a neighborhood robust structural intervention from
the outside will be necessary. Yes, the cycle of poverty; thus, lack of
education, inequality, crime and incarceration rates can be broken, but it will
be absolutely necessary to change a neighborhood’s physical infrastructure, to
dismantle segregated public housing, to create educational systems, for city
and other institutions to considerably investment, and to consult economic
developers. Nevertheless, we must never disregard individuals’ choice in
migration issues we have to be careful not to redistribute, but rather solve
the burden of poverty. Chicago has seen an improvement, but unfortunately,
there will always be “black” and “white” communities…
I agree with you; it will take more than criminal activity to change broken neighborhoods. I believe real activism comes from education, desire, and a willingness to work hard for something. Just taking something that belongs to someone else is short sighted in my opinion.
ReplyDeleteAs I posted under Erica's and Daniel's blogs (and will under Scott's as well), there is a meaningful discussion to be had here, and the JR article definitely got one started. Another way of phrasing the issue is to ask whether JR's approach, ethical debate aside, is likely to be efficacious in Sampson's view. What do you all think?
ReplyDelete